In Short: If you rely on arch support in your closed shoes, sandal season is a problem: flat sandals feel awful, and jamming an orthotic into them doesn't work. The answer isn't a bare footbed or a forced-in insert — it's a sandal with the support already built into it. The Aetrex Jillian ($139.95) has Aetrex Signature Arch Support engineered in, so you keep the support and lose the sneakers.
The summer support gap
You spend the cooler months in supportive shoes or orthotics, your feet feel fine — then it gets warm, you switch to flat sandals, and the arch pain and first-step heel ache come back. That's not a coincidence. Most sandals have a flat, unstructured footbed, so the support you depend on all winter simply disappears in summer.
Why forcing an insole into a sandal doesn't work
The obvious fix — dropping your orthotic into a regular sandal — rarely holds up. Open sandals have nowhere to seat an insole, so it slides, and the straps aren't cut to sit over an added layer. You end up with a shifting insert and a worse fit. The better approach is a sandal built around arch support from the start.
How the Aetrex Jillian is built
The Jillian Braided Quarter Strap Sandal ($139.95) is Aetrex's #1 best-selling sandal, and it's designed for exactly this switch. It has Aetrex Signature Arch Support built into the footbed to align the foot and help relieve common foot pain and plantar fasciitis — the same support principle as your closed shoes. On top of that: a memory foam footbed over an ultra-light cork midsole for all-day walking, a met bar pod to ease ball-of-foot pressure, a padded heel, and fully adjustable hook-and-loop straps so you can dial in the fit (and accommodate feet that changed size, including after pregnancy). The braided leather upper keeps it looking put-together for summer.
A couple of honest specifics shoppers ask about: it has a slight heel lift of about 1.1 inches, not a totally flat footbed; the upper is genuine leather, not a vegan material; and because it's a leather-and-cork everyday sandal, it's made for walking and warm-weather wear rather than for the pool or getting soaked.
Who it's for
The Jillian is the answer if you wear orthotics or arch-support shoes the rest of the year and don't want to give that up in sandals — for travel, everyday summer wear, and long days on your feet in the heat. Support that stays with you when the shoes come off.
Supportive summer sandals: FAQs
I wear orthotics in my sneakers — what do I wear in summer? A sandal with arch support built in, rather than a flat sandal or a forced-in insert. The Jillian has Aetrex Signature Arch Support engineered into the footbed.
Is it better to buy a supportive sandal or put insoles in a regular one? A built-in sandal works better — insoles slide in open sandals and throw off the strap fit. The Jillian is designed around the support from the start.
Does the Jillian have a heel, and is it leather? It has a slight heel lift of about 1.1 inches and a genuine leather upper. It's an everyday walking sandal, not a water or pool sandal.
Shop the full range at aetrex.com.
Share:
House Shoes for Numb Feet, Swelling, and Steady Footing
House Shoes for Numb Feet, Swelling, and Steady Footing