Description

Step into comfort and style with the Erica Casual Sneakers. These Mary Jane-inspired sneakers are designed to elevate your everyday look. Featuring a convenient hook and loop strap, they offer ease of wear and a secure fit. With a lightweight UltraSky™ midsole and durable rubber outsole, the Erica Casual Sneakers ensure all-day comfort and stability. Each Aetrex shoe is anatomically designed based on data and learnings from over 50 million global foot scans. This ensures you’re getting the best fit for your feet and premium support for your body from the ground up.

SKU: CA404W36

Details
Comfort
  • Adjustability: Hook and Loop Strap
  • Removable Insoles: Yes
Materials
  • Upper Material: Leather
  • Midsole Material: Midsole Material: Lightweight EVA foam for comfort durability
  • Outsole Material: Rubber
Measurements
  • Heel Height : 1.25”
Care Instructions
  • For light cleaning, wipe with a soft, slightly damp cloth.
  • For deeper cleaning, mix three parts water and one-part mild detergent.
  • Use a clean cloth to gently rub any stains in a circular motion.
  • For stubborn spots or discoloration, apply Leather Shoe Lotion Cleaner
Size Chart

Make sure you are standing, wearing the socks or stockings you will wear with your new shoes. Using one of the following charts, convert your U.S. shoe size to EU.

IN BETWEEN SIZES? Aetrex recommends you size up for footwear and Orthotics

HEEL-TOE MEASUREMENT
WOMEN'S - US
WOMEN'S - EU
MEN'S - US
MEN'S - EU
KIDS - US
7.2" - 7.5" 7.9" 8.2" 8.5" 8.7" 8.8" 8.9" 9.0" 9.2" 9.3" 9.5" 9.7" 9.8" 10.0" 10.2" 10.4" 10.5" 10.7" 10.8" 11.0" 11.2" 11.3" 11.5" 11.7" 11.9" 12.0"
-- -- -- -- 5 5.5 -- 6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5 12 -- -- -- -- -- --
-- -- -- -- 35 35 -- 36 36 37 38 38 39 40 40 41 42 42 43 43 -- -- -- -- -- --
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5 12 12.5 13 13.5 14
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 39 40 41 42 42 43 43 44 45 45 46 47 47 48 48
C12/13 Y1 Y2 Y3 -- -- Y4 -- Y5 -- Y6 -- Y7 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
← Scroll horizontally to see all sizes →
Extended Holiday Returns

All items purchased between November 1, 2026 through December 24, 2026 are eligible for returns until January 31, 2027.

When you choose Aetrex, you make the healthy choice. Wear the shoes or Aetrex Orthotics and if you are not completely satisfied, return them to us. If you need detailed step-by-step instructions, please visit our FAQ page for further guidance.

The refund will be processed to the original form of payment and should be reflected in your account within 5 to 7 days from the day of the drop-off.

A return fee of $5.95 will be automatically deducted when processing your return.

Shipping charges from the original order are non-refundable.

Helps With

  • arch pain icon

    Arch Pain

  • ball of foot pain icon

    Ball of Foot Pain

  • heel pain icon

    Heel Pain

  • high instep icon

    High Instep

  • metatarsalgia icon

    Metatarsalgia

  • plantar fasciitis icon

    Plantar Fasciitis

Load video: Erica Features PDP Video

Why Customers Love Erica Casual Sneakers - Bronze

Overall rating: 4.075472 / 5 from 53 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Summary topics

Review topics: ["fit","feel","color","look","comfort","style","shoes","support","insole","sneakers","arch","socks"].

Review highlights

Reviews

Very tight on the seam

"Very tight on the seam that runs over the toes; insole is hard and aggravating for plantar fasciitis."

— Tawnya B. (1/5)

The sneakers are comfortable and

"The sneakers are comfortable and cute. The need solid socks, not a plaid or print but they're easy to get into and out of, no laces."

— Virginia H. (4/5)

Very comfortable and supportive, love

"Very comfortable and supportive, love the look"

— Corrine A. (5/5)

Erica Sneakers

"Very comfortable shoe. Great arch support too."

— Charlotte W. (5/5)

Cute and comfortable shoe. Received

"Cute and comfortable shoe. Received lots of compliments. Soft comfort but there was a little rubbing on the heel during break in, but overall very comfortable."

— Rochelle G. (4/5)

Very cute shoe. I did

"Very cute shoe. I did insert my own insole as I felt I needed better arch support. So far this is working well."

— Mary D. (5/5)

The color is much darker

"The color is much darker than represented."

— Liz B. (4/5)

I like the shoes because

"I like the shoes because they have arch support which I need for my feet."

— Norma R. (4/5)

Comfy walking shoe. Well made,

"Comfy walking shoe. Well made, as usual from Aetrex. Love wearing this shoe."

— Jeannine R. (5/5)

Erin Mary Janes are fabulous

"I have this shoe in every color. I was recently diagnosed with Parkinson’s, and had to get rid of many shoes because they affected my balance negatively. The supportive insole and strap across the top were my salvation. Now I have lovely shoes that are adjustable, comfortable and classy. Thanks, Aetrex. Don’t hesitate."

— Joyce B. (5/5)

Q&A

How dark are the tan option?
Hi Marta, The Erica Sneakers in tan is almost like a tan-brown hue.
Is the toe box roomy? I've got bunions and severe hammer toes. Is there something similar with a mesh outer.
Hi DB, The Erica does have a roomy toe box, but we encourage you to try them as that is still the best way to determine fit. We do not have a similar mary-jane style sneaker with a mesh upper, but we recommend looking at the Teagan which has a stretchy-knit material, or the Danika which has a thick outer sole but has a mesh upper. https://www.aetrex.com/collections/shop?q=teagan&tab=products https://www.aetrex.com/collections/shop?q=Danika+Arch+Support+Sneaker&tab=products
Is the Erica casual sneaker roomy enough in toe for someone with bunions?
Hi Marilyn, The Erica does have a roomy toe box, but we encourage you to try them as that is still the best way to determine fit. In the event they aren’t to your satisfaction, you may return the sneakers within 30 days of the purchase date provided they were not marked final sale at the time the order was placed. For more information on returns, please visit https://www.aetrex.com/pages/returns-exchanges.
I just bought these in Navy and want to purchase them in black in Size 42. They are currently out of stock. When will they be available in my size, and I would love to see a silver/gray option, as well. Super comfy!
Hi Linda, We're glad to hear you find the Erica comfortable! As of this writing, the Erica Casual Sneakers in size 42US are available in all variants.